For Songwriters
Switching PROs: What Songwriters Should Know Before Leaving ASCAP or BMI
By the Starchild Music team · November 22, 2026 · 6 min read

The short answer
You can switch PROs, but Songtrust says it can't recommend it: it is slow, royalties can be delayed or lost, and exit rules limit when you can leave. BMI asks for at least a two-year term, ASCAP has set windows, and an unrecouped advance can block you. Confirm the rules with your PRO, tell your publisher and plan for a gap before you resign.
It is the end of the year and you are looking at your royalty statements. Maybe a friend earns more at another PRO. Maybe your publisher moved. Maybe you simply want a fresh start in January. Before you resign, know that switching is possible, but it is slower and riskier than it looks.
This guide covers why switching is hard, what can block it, how the exit rules work in general and a plan for doing it carefully. It is general information, not legal or tax advice. Rules change, so confirm them with your PRO before you act.
The short answer
Songtrust's help center answers whether you can switch with: you can, but we can't recommend it. It calls switching a major headache because of delayed royalties, possible lost income and fees. Its longer guide, updated in 2023, calls the process arduous, with possible royalty delays and lost revenue for years.
That does not mean never switch. It means switch for a clear reason, with a plan, and not because of a rumor.
What you risk
- Delays. Songtrust says societies operate quarterly, so re-registration can take a year or more, and royalties may be held or lost meanwhile.
- Old registrations. Usage reported on old cue sheets with your outdated PRO information may not pay you until you find and fix the error.
- Sync visibility. Music supervisors often check PRO databases, so a lag in updating your affiliation could cost you a request.
- Different payment methods. Some societies pay on actual usage data, some use polling, and some pay only above a threshold, so your income mix may change. This is most important if you rely on TV, streaming or radio.
- Slow overseas money. Songtrust says international payments are slow and may still go to your old society. A 2018 Hypebot piece from Songtrust warns that foreign royalties already on their way may be delayed for years.
- Fees. Some societies charge membership fees.
What can block you
- A minimum term. Songtrust says BMI asks for at least a two-year term after your initial affiliation date. The 2018 Hypebot piece says terms are usually between one and five years, and can depend on how many songs you registered and how much you earn.
- A window. ASCAP has no minimum term but has specific windows when you can request to leave. Miss it and you wait for the next one.
- An unrecouped advance or adjustment. The 2018 Hypebot piece says either can block a switch until it is repaid or the term ends.
- Your publisher. In the U.S., a writer must be represented by a publishing entity at the same PRO, according to Songtrust. If you move, your publisher or administrator usually has to move with you, and it may have its own resignation process and window.
How the process usually works
Songtrust's switching guide gives examples of how different societies handle it: an online request within a window at ASCAP, a certified letter with a notice period at BMI, a hand-signed letter at PRS and three months' notice at SACEM. Those are examples, not current rules, so read yours.
The Hypebot piece lists the order of work: read your current PRO's resignation rules, contact the PRO to confirm the process before you start, plan for income during the gap, decide which songs will transfer and choose the new PRO, then notify your publisher.
Expect your old society to keep licensing songs you registered with it for a time. The Hypebot piece says your old society will continue to license the songs you have already registered with it before you can move them to the new society.
Worked example: should Sam switch?
Sam joined a PRO 14 months ago and wants to move because a friend likes another one. Sam checks the exit rules and finds a minimum term that has not ended. Sam also has two songs that earn small amounts from TV and some songs registered with an administrator. Waiting avoids a delay and a rule problem. In the meantime, Sam can make sure every song is registered correctly, talk with the administrator about its plan and write down the reason for wanting to leave.
If after a year the reason still holds, Sam has a clearer decision and a date to aim for. Two things changed from before: Sam knows the rules, and Sam can act at the right time.
A safer plan
- Write down why you want to switch. Fees, payment method, publisher requirement or something else.
- Read your PRO's current resignation rules and your own agreement, and note the date you joined.
- Call or message the PRO to confirm the process and window before you file anything.
- Ask your publisher or administrator what it needs and when. It may have its own steps.
- Make sure no gap opens between leaving one PRO and joining the next, and plan how to cover any slow months.
- Check that each song's splits and registrations are clean before they move.
If you are not sure
If you are on the fence, a more useful year-end task may be tidying what you have. See our year-end royalty and registration checklist and the songwriter tax paperwork guide. For new songs, our guide to which PRO a new songwriter can join covers the starting choice.
A last note for songwriters who license songs to artists. Your PRO choice does not change who owns the song. On Starchild, partners keep their copyright and earn 50% of each sale, minus the payment fee, so a PRO switch affects the royalties after release, not your licensing. See how to sell your songs.
Sources
- Songtrust Help: Can I Switch My Performing Rights Organization (PRO) Affiliation?
- Songtrust Blog: Switching Your Performing Rights Organization, What to Consider (updated May 15, 2023)
- Hypebot (Songtrust): Swapping Your Performing Rights Organization, What To Consider (Aug 1, 2018)
- Songtrust Help: Can I Be Represented by a Publisher That Is Not Affiliated With the Same PRO as Myself? (United States PROs)
Sell your songs
Partners keep their copyright and earn 50% of each sale, minus the payment fee.