For Songwriters

Which PRO Should a New Songwriter Join? What ASCAP, BMI, SESAC and GMR Are and How to Choose

By the Starchild Music team · November 17, 2026 · 6 min read

A bright open doorway in a sunny courtyard with two identical painted wooden gates side by side, one blue and one green, a small brass key lying on a stone step and a guitar case resting by the wall

The short answer

The U.S. has four performing rights organizations (ASCAP, BMI, SESAC and GMR), but SESAC and GMR are invitation-only, so a new songwriter chooses between ASCAP and BMI. Both are nonprofits that must accept qualified writers, so the choice rests on current fees, term and exit rules, and how you want to handle publishing. Join one before your songs are released, and check the terms on the PRO's own site first.

You have written songs, someone is about to release one, and a friend says you need to join a PRO. Then you search and find a pile of arguments about which one is best. The honest answer is shorter than the arguments: your real choices are two, and the differences are mostly about terms, not magic.

This guide covers what a PRO does, how the four U.S. PROs differ, what to compare and what to do first. It is general information, not legal advice. Fees and terms change, so confirm them with the PRO before you join.

What a PRO does

A performing rights organization collects royalties when songs are performed publicly and pays them to its members. The Congressional Research Service describes the system this way: licensees generally get a blanket license that covers any work in the PRO's catalog, and the PROs split the public performance royalties they collect among members based on play frequency and other factors.

In plain terms, if your song plays on streaming, radio, TV or in a venue, your PRO is the body that collects and pays the writer's share. It is not the same as The MLC, which handles streaming mechanical royalties. Our guide to how streams and radio turn into royalties explains the difference, and the writer's share and publisher's share guide shows what each half is.

The four U.S. PROs

The CRS report names four U.S. PROs and says ASCAP and BMI are the two largest, handling public performance rights for most musical works. Songtrust's help center agrees that four PROs collect royalties in the U.S.

  • ASCAP and BMI. Both are nonprofits. They have long operated under consent decrees with the Department of Justice, and the CRS notes that they must accept as members any songwriter who meets minimum requirements.
  • SESAC and GMR. Both operate as for-profit corporations, are not bound by the consent decrees and are open by invitation only, per the CRS report.

That is why Songtrust says that you will only be able to choose between ASCAP and BMI, as the others are invitation-only. If SESAC or GMR ever invites you, that is a separate decision to weigh, ideally with a music lawyer.

What to compare before you choose

  • Cost. Some societies charge a sign-up fee and some do not, and Songtrust's affiliation guide says to have a card ready for any sign-up fees. Check the current figure on each PRO's join page.
  • Term and exit rules. Songtrust says BMI asks for at least a two-year term after your initial affiliation date, and that ASCAP has no minimum term but has specific windows when you can request to leave. Rules differ, and Songtrust's switching guide says to read them before you sign. Our switching guide goes deeper.
  • How you are paid. Songtrust's switching guide notes that some societies pay on actual usage data, some use polling, and some pay only above a threshold. That matters most if you earn from TV, streaming or radio.
  • Fit with your publisher. Songtrust says a U.S. writer must be represented by a publishing entity at the same PRO, so if you plan to sign with a publisher or administrator, ask which PRO it works with.

You will find plenty of opinions that one PRO is better for TV or live music. Those claims shift over time and rarely come with data you can check. A safer test is to read each PRO's current terms and ask people who earn from the kind of music you make.

How to join

Songtrust's affiliation guide lists the steps for a U.S. PRO: visit the PRO's site and choose whether you join as a songwriter or a publisher, enter your personal information, list any earlier affiliations, check the details and read the terms before you submit. Joining as a songwriter gives you an IPI number, which identifies you and links you to your catalog.

You apply with the society directly. Songtrust requires you to be a PRO member before you use its service, then you add your IPI number.

After you join

If your songs are licensed to artists

A PRO membership does not conflict with licensing your songs. On Starchild, partners keep their copyright and earn 50% of each sale, minus the payment fee, and the artist who licenses a song records and releases their own version. When that recording is played, the royalties above are paid through your registrations. Our guide to who registers a licensed song explains who does what. To list songs, see how to sell your songs.

Do this today

  • Read the current join terms for ASCAP and BMI side by side: fees, term and exit rules.
  • Ask your publisher or administrator, if you have one, which PRO it works with.
  • Pick one and apply before your next release.
  • Save your IPI number and the agreement date somewhere safe, since the date can decide when you can leave.

Sources

Sell your songs

Partners keep their copyright and earn 50% of each sale, minus the payment fee.