Exclusive Licensing

Can Other Singers Perform a Song Live While You Hold the Exclusive License?

By the Starchild Music team · November 21, 2026 · 6 min read

A cozy small-stage corner of a cafe with a stool, an acoustic guitar on a stand, a microphone and warm string lights, a handwritten set list taped to a stand, empty and ready for an evening show

The short answer

Not automatically. A song has a composition and a recording, and U.S. copyright law treats public performance of each differently. An exclusive on your recording is mainly about who can release the song, so what it says about live shows depends on the words in your contract.

You hold the exclusive on a song for the holidays, and you notice another singer posted that they will play it at an open mic. Does that break your exclusive? The short answer is that it usually does not by default, but your contract decides.

It helps to separate two things that people lump together: releasing a recording, and performing a song on a stage. This guide explains how the law treats them and what to read in your own license. It is general information, not legal advice.

A song is two copyrights

Every recorded song has two parts: the composition, meaning the melody and lyrics, and the sound recording, meaning a particular recorded performance of it. Copyright law handles them separately.

The Copyright Office's overview shows this in the list of owner rights. For musical works, the owner has the right to perform the work publicly. For sound recordings, the public performance right applies "only by means of a digital audio transmission." Section 106 of the Copyright Act says the same: item (4) covers public performance of musical and other listed works, and item (6) covers sound recordings by digital audio transmission.

What that means on a stage

A singer performing a song live at a venue is performing the composition. The right involved sits with the writers and publishers, not with whoever owns a particular recording. That is why, in general, a license about a recording does not control who can sing the song live.

The law also defines when a performance counts as public: at a place open to the public, or any place where a substantial number of people gather. So a coffee shop gig counts, and a living-room rehearsal does not.

In practice, venues usually deal with this through blanket licenses from performing rights organizations, which cover large catalogs of songs, and the venue is commonly the one expected to hold them. Check with the venue and with the PRO if you are a performer who is unsure. We did not find a primary source we could cite on exactly how venues are charged, so treat that as a question to ask them.

What your exclusive license may add

An exclusive license is a contract, so it can say more than the default rules. Read your agreement for:

  • The scope of the grant: is the exclusivity about releasing recordings, or does it mention performance, video or other uses?
  • Your own live rights: a standard license covers performing the song live yourself, and you should confirm this in your paperwork.
  • Any limit on the writer: some licenses promise the writer will not license the same use to anyone else during the term. That is a promise between you and the writer, and it does not reach other singers who simply perform it at a gig.
  • Territory and term: the dates when your exclusivity starts and ends.

What exclusivity does protect

In most artist licenses the main thing an exclusive protects is a release window: for the term, the song is off the market for new licenses to other artists. It does not make you the only voice that can ever sing it. Our guide on what an exclusive license can't promise covers earlier licensees, and the question of covers covers new recordings.

If your goal is that your version feels new to listeners, plan around that. The guide to how exclusivity shapes a song's story has ideas for building your release without needing to control every stage.

Holiday gigs: a short example

Elena holds a three-month exclusive on a winter ballad and releases it in late November. A friend plays the same song at a December open mic, and Elena worries. She re-reads her agreement and finds the exclusivity is about who can license the recording rights for the term, with nothing about live shows. The friend is performing the composition at a venue, which is a separate matter. Elena decides to schedule her own live performances and a lyric video instead, and to tag the venue. Elena and her friend are made up.

Do this today

  • Open your license and look at the grant and any live-performance wording.
  • Write down your term dates in your calendar, including holiday gigs.
  • Ask the venue whether they hold a PRO license for the shows you book.
  • Plan your own live dates, since your standard license covers performing the song live yourself.
  • If your contract is unclear, ask the writer or a music attorney before you act.

This is general information, not legal advice, and contracts differ. If you are planning holiday shows, see choosing a holiday song to release this season and browse holiday songs.

Sources

Find a song to license

Every song on Starchild can be heard in different styles and in your key before you license it.