AI & Music
Suno Wants the Second Universal and Sony Lawsuit Paused. What a Stay Means for Artists and Songwriters
By the Starchild Music team · November 16, 2026 · 6 min read

The short answer
Suno has asked a federal court to pause the second lawsuit from Universal and Sony until the first one decides whether its training was fair use. In a filing reported on November 16, 2026, the labels answered that they accept a pause on some discovery but not a full freeze, which they say could run into 2028. No ruling on the motion has been reported, and nothing about fair use has been decided.
Short answer: a stay is a pause, not a decision. Suno has asked a federal court to freeze the second major-label lawsuit against it while the first one moves forward. The reasoning is simple. If the first case decides that Suno's training was fair use, the second case may lose some of its legal theories. On November 16, 2026, Digital Music News reported that Universal and Sony filed a roughly 20-page opposition. They say a full freeze is too much.
This article explains the two cases, the dispute over the pause and what it means if you write or record songs. It reports what the parties argue, based on one trade report. It is general information, not legal advice.
The two cases in plain words
- The first case, UMG v. Suno I (No. 1:24-cv-11611), is the earlier suit against Suno by major labels. Digital Music News says its fair use question is central to the second case.
- The second case, UMG v. Suno II (No. 1:26-cv-14275), was filed on September 18, 2026 by Universal and Sony. Music Business Worldwide reports that it accuses Suno of copying 60,202 sound recordings without a license and calls Suno's newest v6 models "the fruit of the same poisoned tree."
- Warner Music Group is not a plaintiff. It settled with Suno in November 2025, and Suno says its v6 models were developed with Warner, BMG and Believe, as Music Business Worldwide reports.
How the second case came about
According to Digital Music News, the majors first tried to add about 60,000 more works to the first case. The judge denied that request, saying it would delay resolution "for an indefinite period of time," but left room for a follow-up complaint. The labels then filed the separate second action, which targets Suno's v6 models.
What Suno asks for
In late October, Suno asked the court to pause the second case until the first one is resolved. Its argument, as Digital Music News summarizes it:
- If the court finds Suno's conduct was fair use in the first case, that could remove liability theories in the second.
- If the court finds that YouTube's technical protections do not support a claim under Section 1201(a) of the copyright law, that claim could fall away too.
- Running both cases at once, with views on fair use that differ so sharply, would create duplicate work and possibly unnecessary burdens.
What Universal and Sony answer
The labels agree on one point. They say a fair use ruling in the first case will be "instructive" for the second. They do not agree to a full stay. Digital Music News reports their main points:
- A full stay could last into 2028 while Suno keeps training, releasing and earning money from new models.
- They accept a temporary pause on work-by-work discovery into who owns the 60,000-plus recordings.
- Delay would hurt the record: engineers may leave, memories may fade and training pipelines may change or be replaced before discovery into v6 begins.
- They propose a partial stay, with discovery from the first case usable in the second. They say that removes the duplication Suno worries about.
- They want discovery to reach Suno's v6 products, ongoing model training and its finances and commercial footprint, including new features, fundraising and investor presentations.
Other fights in the first case
Digital Music News also reports that lawyers met in early November to try to resolve several discovery disagreements in the first case. Fights over subpoenas to outside parties are ongoing. The report lists Nvidia, the Mechanical Licensing Collective, several Suno investors, Apple and DistroKid. Our earlier article on the DistroKid subpoena explains why a distributor's data matters to the fair use argument.
What it means for artists and songwriters
Nothing changes for you today. No court has said whether training an AI music model on recordings is fair use. This is why the stay matters: if the first case reaches a fair use ruling, the second case, and possibly others, will be argued in its shadow. Fair use cases turn on facts, so a ruling on one company's training may not settle every other tool.
Our look at Anthropic's IPO filing shows the same uncertainty from the other side: that company says the law on AI training "has not been authoritatively resolved." Here is what to do while the courts decide:
- Register your songs and recordings with the U.S. Copyright Office. Registration is a step you control, and suits over U.S. works generally need it.
- Keep records of what you wrote, when you wrote it and who has licensed it.
- Read the terms of any AI tool you use, especially what it says about training on what you upload.
- If you record songs written by others, get a license in writing and keep it with your project files.
Starchild's catalog is built on human-written songs that artists license to record and release their own versions. Every license comes with a certificate naming the writers, which anyone can check at /verify. Browse songs for artists.
What is pending (as of November 16)
- A ruling on Suno's motion to stay: full, partial or denied.
- Whether the court in the first case reaches fair use, and when.
- Whether discovery from the first case can be reused in the second.
- The outcome of the subpoena fights over outside parties' data.
Sources
- Digital Music News: UMG v. Suno II, stay motion and discovery dispute (November 16, 2026)
- Music Business Worldwide: Suno launches Bridge, an app that drops AI stems into Ableton Live (November 16, 2026)
- Music Business Worldwide: Reservoir expands copyright lawsuits against Suno and Anthropic to more than 2,500 songs combined (November 13, 2026)
Find a song to license
Every song on Starchild can be heard in different styles and in your key before you license it.